I noticed in SharpTools when I added my EcoBee it was displaying a temp that didn't match the display. Looking at the EcoBee device I see Current State of Temperature value matches the display at 70 degrees. SharpTools was displaying 73.5 which is a value called ThermostatSetPoint. Does anybody kno…

I think we are on the same page. The thermostatOperatingState should be idle if the thermostat is actually idle though. The only time the thermostatOperatingState should show heating is when the furnace is actively heating the home. If the thermostatOperatingState always shows heating when the mode…

[image] josh: I think we are on the same page. The thermostatOperatingState should be idle if the thermostat is actually idle though. The only time the thermostatOperatingState should show heating is when the furnace is actively heating the home. If the thermostatOperatingState always shows hea…

I use WATO to pull Thermostat Operating State out of my ecobee so that I can turn on Ceiling fans when my AC is running. Works really well. [image] [RELEASE] WATO - When any Attribute Then this cmd Otherwise that cmd ⚙️ Custom Apps and Drivers i was trying to get Rules M…

@ryan780 are you specifically using it with the thermostatOperatingState attribute from the Ecobee? Based on what Drew and Jason mentioned, it doesn't sound like the device is reporting the values I would have expected for the thermostatOperatingState. The expected values for the thermostatOperatin…

I should have mentioned... I'm also using the ported version of Ecobee Suite. The native implementation doesn't report back operating state correctly. [image] Ecobee App/Driver Port from SmartThings 🚧 Developers So I spent a little time getting storageanarchy 's ecobee …

@Ryan780 Eh... The built in driver reports heating when heating, and cooling when cooling in thermostatOperatingState... So it reports operating state at least semi-right... It shows Auto when idle, which isn't right, but that hasn't affected much on my end. If the Ecobee Suite port reports it fas…

[image] JasonJoelOld: So it reports operating state at least semi-right... It shows Auto when idle, Only if you have mode = Auto. If mode is Heating, it always reports heating even when Idle.

It does not always report heating when heating and cooling when cooling no matter what mode you are in. It reports the correct state when you change the temp manually but not when it "recovers" to an already set temp. At least thats the way it worked with the native integration 2 months ago.

[image] drew: [image] JasonJoelOld: So it reports operating state at least semi-right... It shows Auto when idle, Only if you have mode = Auto. If mode is Heating, it always reports heating even when Idle. Oh!! Yeah, that's not good. I didn't know that, as mine is almost always in auto…

EcoBee Question

Get Help

Ryan780 December 21, 2018, 9:36pm 15

I should have mentioned... I'm also using the ported version of Ecobee Suite. The native implementation doesn't report back operating state correctly.