Zigbee non-functional, but shows Online

Ty for the reply!

Iโ€™ll try taking the backup locally and do a restore from the downloaded copy. I have done restores from the ui but never downloaded/uploaded them. The reset triggered with a restore is the same as factory resetting the device and restoring it. So there is nothing to be gained with the extra steps to factory reset it?

I tried the second with no change.

I have tried to readd the bulbs and they never showed in the hub with it in zigbee pairing mode. Reset the bulbs many times and they never showed back up. I tried two different bulbs before I reset the zigbee radio to see if that made a difference

Everything else on the hub is working as expected but it seems that zigbee is refusing to work.

Correct, and its not a "factory reset" per-se because it does not reset the radio data, only the hub database.

Is the Zigbee radio even showing it is online in the details page? Had another user recently where it would not go online and doing the backup/restore fixed it. That's the main reason I suggested that.

It shows as online, and if I reboot the radio it goes through the various statuses fine. I never get any data when i do a "Scan Channels" but i never did that before i started having troubles so i don't know if that would normally show anything. "network graph (beta)" shows 0/45 devices and will make a tenative connection to 0000 and nothing more. my logs show this about every 5 min

profileId:0x0, clusterId:0x8032, sourceEndpoint:0, destinationEndpoint:0 , groupId:0, lastHopLqi:255, lastHopRssi:0

If it weren't otherwise reporting fine, it seems like the hardware is having issues

There is nothing else anyone can really suggest until you try the backup / restore.

If it still fails after that maybe support can check the engineering logs, I would submit a warranty claim at support.hubitat.com , even if it is out of warranty a little.

1 Like

okie. I'll give that a go tonight

tyty

--Ryan

That sounds like the 'hub on a quiet Zigbee network sending itself a message to see if the radio is alive scenario' described here: Zigbee log showing device 0000(0) - :bellhop_bell: Get Help - Hubitat

Apparently the Zigbee radio in the hub thinks the mesh is silent... see the post by Chuck Schwer, former HE employee.

So i have about 45 zigbee devices and most are on right now. I should see something in this? or would this only show devices active in its own mesh?

You should at least see your own hub, but it is also known to randomly not work at all for some people (myself included). So being totally blank could just mean its not working at all for your hub.

I've seen that the output of the channel scan feature varies, depending on hub type.

Because of a quirk (manifested by C-7 and C-8, which evidently never display their own PAN ID/Extended PAN ID in the output of the channel scan) if you have a lone C-7 or C-8 (with no other active Zigbee PANs within range) seeing a completely blank channel scan may be "normal".

I've got 3 hubs; C-3 on 2.3.6.135, and C-7 and C-8 (those last two are on latest beta firmware). In addition to those PANs I also have a couple of non-HE Zigbee hubs which get detected by channel scans. What I've seen is that C-3, C-7 and C-8 each produce different output when doing a channel scan.

From my experience with these hubs (can't speak for C-4 or C-5) only the C-3 will display its own PAN ID and Extended PAN ID along with other detected PANs, though it displays all Extended PAN ID's in reversed byte order.

C-7 won't display its own PAN ID/Extended PAN ID ( it does display other PANs, but shows Extended PAN IDs with byte order reversed like C-3).

C-8 (at least with latest beta) won't display its own PAN ID/Extended PAN ID, but does display other detected PANs (and displays correct byte ordering of all Extended PAN IDs).

1 Like

Interestingly on my C8 (on latest beta) the channel scan displays both PAN ID and the Extended PAN ID correctly. My C7 (also on beta) shows correct PAN ID and "scrambled" extended PAN ID.

C8: Showing itself and the C7 correctly


C7: Showing only the PAN IDs correctly for the C8 and C7.


Lol... weird. There was one recent beta where my C-8's scan never showed anything; the next beta 'fixed' that (except for not showing itself). At least C-8 gets all the Extended ID's formatted correctly (when it decides to show them):

Here's the channel scans produced by my C-3, C-7 and C-8=; only the C-3 shows all three HE PANs

C-3 scan:

C-7's scan:

C-8's scan:

1 Like

Change is our only constant... :wink:

1 Like

I think this was overlooked in @jtp10181 โ€™s reply. AFAIK resetting the radio doesnโ€™t delete the devices from your database, but does make it necessary to reset and rejoin all of them as they are no longer connected. If you have a cloud backup, you can restore the radio from that (C-8 only), otherwise the backup only restores the database, not the z radios.

This

You need the full quote

If the devices list on the Zigbee details was not cleared after this supposed reset, it was either not a full zigbee radio reset, or it failed to reset it. So the answer the original question, no that is not normal.

He also said later that he tried pairing some bulbs to the hub again after resetting the bulbs and they would not pair up.

So maybe what is needed is an actual full zigbee radio reset along with pairing all the device again.... if nothing else works that could be a last resort, if the reset will work.

When I reset the zigbee radio on my C-8 last week, the devices remained listed until I reset the database. I assumed that it was normal behavior. @gopher.ny or @bobbyD

1 Like

So i have tried multiple times to reset and the device list never clears. typing "reset" in the space provided and clicking the red reset button. The radio cycles through some status changes but then the page reloads and it looks the same

If i do a hard reset, then import a backup in would that achieve a radio reset? at this point I have work to get back to functional either way. I am just trying to get zigbee working agian otherwise i need to find a solution to getting those devices working again. I restored a downloaded backup today and will try and add a device again when i get home.

Listed where? in Zigbee details or in the devices list? The Zigbee details list should be tied to the radio data and the hub devices list is tied to the hub database.

EDIT: Apparently a Zigbee reset does not clear the details page out like it does for ZWave, learned something new.

2 Likes

That is right after doing a reset just now. What i am hearing is that means it is not successfully resetting?

No I guess I was wrong, sorry not a total Zigbee expert. Apparently a Zigbee reset does not clear all the devices out of the details page like it does for ZWave. But, you would have to pair them again to get them working. I am testing it right now on my dev hub which only had one device paired to it.

You possibly had issues pairing those bulbs if they are normally going through a repeater. So maybe try pairing a closer device and see if that will join.

image

1 Like