Water sensor is wet but valve doesn't close

[physh]

Hopefully my last help request...
Last piece of the puzzle after turning SmartThings off is to get my leak sensors to automatically close my main valve...
I have a basic rule that states that if any leak sensor is wet the valve must be closed. Looking at logs, the automation seems to work, but the valve doesn't close. I can close the valve from the dashboard so it's connected just fine.

Any ideas?

Logs:
[app:66]2021-07-17 20:53:02.671 [info]act: Close valve Main Water Shut Off
2021-07-17 20:53:02.664 [info]evt: Washing Machine Leak Sensor water wet

[snell]

Hopefully that was a test you were running for it and not an actual leak...

[rlithgow1]

Try doing it in HSM and see if that works.

[physh]

That's really interesting. A simple rule doesn't work, but HSM does...?

[rlithgow1]

Hmm.. Maybe @bravenel has some insight

[physh]

Interestingly, my garden watering automation, also involving a valve, does not work either.

[bravenel]

What exactly failed? The rule ran the action to close the valve, according to your logs. If the valve did not close, odds are it's something about the valve device. Does it open/close from its device page?

Which version of Rule is this?

[physh]

@bravenel

If the valve did not close, odds are it's something about the valve device. Does it open/close from its device page?

I can close both valves manually from the device pages, but the basic rules don't seem to work.
Basic Rules 1.0?

[Navat604]

@bravenel

What exactly failed? The rule ran the action to close the valve, according to your logs. If the valve did not close, odds are it's something about the valve device. Does it open/close from its device page?

Which version of Rule is this?

Valve doesn't work with Basic rule. I posted a few weeks back below but never got a chance to look deeper since it's summer and I don't have access to my hub most of the time.

[Released] Basic Rules

You can already do this a multitude of ways in Rule Machine. Here is one: Trigger event: Motion active Actions to run: Wait for event: Motion inactive Wait for event: elapsed time --> 0:05:00 Log: "Motion has stayed inactive for 5 minutes. Do something now." This may look confusing because it triggers on "motion active," but keep in mind that the primary purpose of a trigger is to make your actions run, and you can't get a "motion inactive" event without a "motion active" event first (thoug…

[bravenel]

Looks like the implementation of open/close valve never was completed, only the UI portion was actually done. I will get that fixed and into the next hotfix release.

[physh]

Looks like the latest release fixed it. Thanks!

[rlithgow1]

In the end though wouldn't it have been better to do in HSM than basic rules? (Glad BR is workring for you now)