Support to smart garage opener

That's not really the issue. All WiFi chipset/radios are transmitters and receivers both (how else would the device send data?). The issue is the WiFi dongle being used is configured as a wireless client, where it needs an access point to connect to. The same WiFi dongle could be configured as an access point to provide wireless network services to other wireless clients, but HE would still need something to connect to, and most device/dongle WIFi chipsets can't be both an access point and a client at the same time.

A side note: One could remove the client->server nature of how most people use WiFi networks and setup each client radio in an "ad-hoc network" mode, where there is no centralized access point - each device can talk to every other device directly. Handheld game consoles regularly use this mode to communicate with other handhelds in the area without requiring a central access point (nintendo Switch for example).

I was commenting on the design choice by Hubitat to not include WiFi as an integrated option and speculating the reason could be related to the likelihood of interference between WiFi and Zigbee

Lots of other hubs have combined both 2.4GHz Wifi and ZIgbee radios in the same devices. Wink, Smartthings, Control4, etc. As long as they aren't on the same frequency, they're fine.

1 Like

I'm not saying it doesn't work, only that the potential for interference exists and may explain their design decision.

1 Like