Seeing debug events for contact switch but status does not change

I have a Aeotec Gen 5 Recessed contact switch (Z-Wave) that is acting strangely. If I move it to a certain location in the house (carrying it around by hand) it registers open/close actions. However once I install it in its proper place, the status remains "open". I can see the debug messages in the log for open/close activity when its installed (and not updating):

dev:2642021-12-09 09:59:18.528 pm debug parsed 'zw device: 27, command: 3003, payload: FF , isMulticast: true' to null
dev:2642021-12-09 09:59:14.551 pm debug parsed 'zw device: 27, command: 3003, payload: 00 , isMulticast: true' to null

This is what I see in the logs when it is in a "working" location in the house and is updating status properly:

dev:2642021-12-09 10:01:04.789 pm debugparsed 'zw device: 27, command: 3003, payload: FF , isMulticast: false' to [name:contact, value:open, descriptionText:Front Door Contact was opened]
dev:2642021-12-09 10:01:04.785 pm infoFront Door Contact was opened
dev:2642021-12-09 10:01:04.780 pm debugSensorBinaryReport cmd:SensorBinaryReport(sensorValue:255)
dev:2642021-12-09 10:00:59.700 pm debugparsed 'zw device: 27, command: 3003, payload: 00 , isMulticast: false' to [name:contact, value:closed, descriptionText:Front Door Contact was closed]
dev:2642021-12-09 10:00:59.697 pm infoFront Door Contact was closed
dev:2642021-12-09 10:00:59.691 pm debugSensorBinaryReport cmd:SensorBinaryReport(sensorValue:0)

My question is, why is the debug payload mostly the same (with the exception of the 'isMulticast' bool), yet the hub doesn't seem to recognize it as a contact state update when it is in the location that "does not work"?

I've repair the Z-Wave network several times and let it sit for 24 hours untouched. I even went so far as to put a repeater about 6 feet from the door frame where it is installed, even though the hub is only 12 feet from the doorframe as it is.

I did end up resolving the situation by swapping the device with another and they now both work properly in their new locations.

I'm still quite curious why the hub saw events but did not associate with the device when when it was installed in that particular location.