Old house wiring -- old-style switch loops; solution using in-box module

It's clear from the problems people have that lots of the people doing automation are in what I think of as "new" houses, i.e. much of the wiring is already grounded, and the walls are sheetrock instead of plaster :slight_smile: I've never lived in a house that new myself.

This is probably obvious to anybody comfortable messing with house wiring, but when you have an old-style switch-loop on a ceiling fixture (hot and neutral to to the ceiling box, hot is connected to a wire going down to the wall box with the switch, switched hot comes back from the wall box with the switch and is connected to the ceiling fixture, and neutral is connected just to the ceiling fixture), it's quite easy to convert it so that you have a mechanical switch in the wall that talks to a light module in the ceiling box which controls the actual light.

There's another way, not quite as obvious, that's also useful; Re-purpose the loop wiring to be a normal feed (hot and neutral) down to the box, and wire the light to just be controlled by a module in the ceiling box. Now you don't have any direct button to control the module, but you DO have a wall box with hot and neutral available; you can then install anything, but specifically a scene controller (or a zwave wall switch with no hard-wired load, used as a limited scene controller).

The more I work with this stuff the more I love the in-box modules! They provide so many really interesting possibilities.

2 Likes

Sonoff zbmini in the fixture turns a spst switch into a toggling device without repurposing the switch legs.

1 Like

You're right... this isn't quite as obvious of a solution. This would also work well to wire the fixture as always hot and use a smart bulb. And again, almost any switch or scene controller in the wall.

Their web page doesn't make very clear what's going on in this regard -- in fact it's mostly about the anti-flicker features.

I think one of the big benefits of repurposing the switch loop wiring is that it avoids the flicker issue entirely.

If ON/OFF is acceptable then I agree with the above mentioned Sonoff ZBmini.

I recently installed it for a 3-Way where the switches had only 2 conductors.

image

It not only works very well but it is very easy to wire. Except for wiring two switches together, the ZBmini connections are all screw terminals. This is great when there isn't a lot of room in your box.

1 Like

My 1969 home has no neutrals.

The house I grew up in had knob and tube wiring. I remember my father having to work around gas pipes when he was replacing a ceiling light fixture. Each room used to have a gas lamp hanging from the ceiling.

1 Like

Was it uphill both ways to and from school? And always in the snow?? :rofl:

1 Like

Barefoot too
:roll_eyes:

1 Like

I still have them on the walls in the basement. Fortunately disconnected! Lutron Caseta is my friend.

Yeah, there's still functioning knob-and-tube in this house (less still functioning than when I bought the place; but the complicated back-stair light system where the two halves of the duplex have lights on all 3 floors on their own electrical service is not something I care to replace from scratch; also most of the first-floor ceiling fixtures). Was in 2 of the 3 previous houses as well, though I think I eventually got all of it in the first house (which has since been torn down to become a parking ramp).

Barefoot through the snow of course; I'm in Minnesota, after all.

But--no neutrals? Do you perhaps mean no grounds? (neutrals are white, grounds are green or bare, in modern enough work :slight_smile: ).

1 Like

Now if you left the gas pipes there you could use a pneumatic system to control your lights :slight_smile:

2 Likes

I learned how to be a grease money who rips people off on their car repairs :sunglasses: at Ranken Technical College in St. Louis. Graduated in 1977.

All the clocks in the main building were pneumatic. No second hand. Standing next to one of the clocks you could hear the solenoid cycle and the minute hand would advance one position. Each clock had a constant low pressure air supply.

Haven’t been back to see if they are still working.

1 Like

Interesting.... I've seen electric clocks that advance once every pulse but not pneumatic. Sounds complicated.

Download the Hubitat app