Let's talk thermostats and house comfort

Thanks Matthew appreciate it.

Maybe someone here has a suggestion.

I have a Arduino setup with relays to turn on/off pumps for my hot water heating system. I also have sensors in those heated areas that tell me what the temp is. I have a app that I can set the temp in it and it will do the job. What I am lacking / wanting is a dashboard device / widget that I can use to change the temp. Similar to a dimmer control for a light. That way I wouldn't have to dig into the app settings to change the temp. Is there anything out there that will do this?

How I worked around this is by using an IFTTT WebHook device driver to trigger the IFTTT that would put my ecobee into the right comfort mode.

You can probably find it quickly with a forum search.

Using IFTTT in this situation doesn't but me too much because anything for ecobee control still requires the cloud anyways. But this method does work pretty well.

I then include those virtual buttons in my other rules as needed.

I know i can do that but its not optimal, i would like to lessen the number of hops actions need to take.
Optimaly: HU -> ecobee
Non-optimal: HU -> IFTTT -> ecobee

more points of failure

I know. But until they introduce the integration this is a work around.

I would prefer to have it direct as well.

Are you bypassing Honeywell's TCC by using IFTTT? I haven't worked with IFTTT yet and I'm not really aware of its capabilities.

Also, just fyi, in the driver code that @csteele modified and posted on github, you can change the set points to permanent. There is a default value that is set as temporary.

I'm trying to figure out how I would like to integrate this thermostat with HE, so any input you have would be greatly appreciated.

UPDATE: I just ran across the thread below.

No, IFTTT connects to Honeywell TCC.

Hubitat -> IFTTT -> Honeywell TCC

@csteele Do you have a dedicated thread for your TCC thermostat driver? I couldn't find one, so here I am.

I get sporadic errors - sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. Below is a log that shows two instances of the cool setpoint. At time 9:43, it works; st time 9:44, it fails. Is it possible TCC rate-constrains commands?

09:44:52.393 am errorgroovyx.net.http.HttpResponseException: Unauthorized on line 433 (setCoolingSetpoint)
09:44:51.883 am debugparams = [uri:https://www.mytotalconnectcomfort.com/portal/Device/SubmitControlScreenChanges, headers:[Accept:application/json, text/javascript, */*; q=0.01, DNT:1, Accept-Encoding:gzip,deflate,sdch, Cache-Control:max-age=0, Accept-Language:en-US,en,q=0.8, Connection:keep-alive, Host:mytotalconnectcomfort.com, Referer:https://www.mytotalconnectcomfort.com/portal/Device/Control/597062, X-Requested-With:XMLHttpRequest, User-Agent:Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; WOW64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/28.0.1500.95 Safari/537.36, Cookie:ASP.NET_SessionId=hmw3fevshfxzfnig1kgga5kp;NSC_NZUDD-443-WT=ffffffff090ecc0545525d5f4f58455e445a4a42378b;], body:[DeviceID:597062, SystemSwitch:null, HeatSetpoint:null, CoolSetpoint:80, HeatNextPeriod:null, CoolNextPeriod:null, StatusHeat:2, StatusCool:2, FanMode:null, ThermostatUnits:F]]
09:44:51.872 am debugsetting cool setpoint to 80
09:44:51.870 am debugsetting heat setpoint to null
09:44:51.868 am debughttps://www.mytotalconnectcomfort.com/portal/Device/SubmitControlScreenChanges
09:44:51.866 am debugExecuting 'setStatus'
09:44:51.865 am debugcookies: ASP.NET_SessionId=hmw3fevshfxzfnig1kgga5kp;NSC_NZUDD-443-WT=ffffffff090ecc0545525d5f4f58455e445a4a42378b;
09:44:51.863 am debugAdding cookie to collection: NSC_NZUDD-443-WT=ffffffff090ecc0545525d5f4f58455e445a4a42378b
09:44:51.861 am debugAdding cookie to collection: ASP.NET_SessionId=hmw3fevshfxzfnig1kgga5kp
09:44:51.857 am debuggroovyx.net.http.HttpResponseDecorator$HeadersDecorator@7fe23bcc
09:44:51.855 am debugRequest was successful, 302
09:44:51.273 am infoExecuting 'login'

09:43:44.895 am infoExecuting 'login'
09:43:23.370 am debugSetStatus is 1 now
09:43:23.363 am debugRequest was successful, 200
09:43:22.454 am debugparams = [uri:https://www.mytotalconnectcomfort.com/portal/Device/SubmitControlScreenChanges, headers:[Accept:application/json, text/javascript, */*; q=0.01, DNT:1, Accept-Encoding:gzip,deflate,sdch, Cache-Control:max-age=0, Accept-Language:en-US,en,q=0.8, Connection:keep-alive, Host:mytotalconnectcomfort.com, Referer:https://www.mytotalconnectcomfort.com/portal/Device/Control/597062, X-Requested-With:XMLHttpRequest, User-Agent:Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; WOW64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/28.0.1500.95 Safari/537.36, Cookie:ASP.NET_SessionId=dwpnk03421a5eo2zymmlk2kv;.ASPXAUTH_TRUEHOME=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;.ASPXAUTH_TRUEHOME_AT=ZpvJ0Pqtdb-fa1zzTc-Lj-lotdRfnZJZ79lGrnSMSGd2JmpLI7zKCXJydTg5sqLPdaRb_vp0D5xVPtI6KBKs6AaS-ouJMDd8TSmq2Ya-ETqMrhALGf0KGRi2Ug-h5cRxBkQ8mKMnN3fplovLrcD8wBAhGoyxAHMgjgtQeCvCzQ_xjvbR0R066IJSpnwP5G30PumWjRaGB9473140baY_IkfTdETV56TR2LEGTAppOssm9J8UnYdFQWnGJMZZ8lukEQEe5Ah1L6rOaADkWiKA5pOT6FqZCPQcH7TYoR1PXioSP5FF1o3JU2xRIvyBaN1fGHbGHotxn3F6haWxs1g-mphFz9H1VdyeBMAKXWVKvp5G7nbi1B4szWzeXLYDtb7RUZ6BwmrYO6JuXHqXKymWIPPf5s0U7rAxMGhdHgxYypi094pX4k8xheDOltGGGE8crBgEvXxrf9mSOOa8qGp7Mw7fHRIfLLwzAvRtF6PcWQ44V3nGxQZ6-oHh3hUdHKUOS8cWv8S-guWWoZlM4G7JESylZhlnaqMhdMXw-iUwVANxzqsrNQvT3CUndWTmADJYEgPlYhLpCLDJci_oief5D7yN8Rb8LznqYBGSdeP4f3b50E1X0Uq-h0-NTGNxjG6ju7DUW0MKOJu42rlBj-Y5OSruynBaMqBLH5LBBg3wCehnaCLG;.ASPXAUTH_TRUEHOME_RT=daCzZQAWmgEfMAD9-Srm-dHIsXqblZDuIYomwdGTNAiXuvaadJwKsLrz7Se1Rl9C9QUQ4xRok8yczTfFCfrxwDS6WIDDERiZO8yOBRGwI-xxkrVIXuKx2oENlamp53TYcKa2lJqGDnlfbn4hBdDYNNKFFEsfXJDqKIUFzCNDD4GhiBqez_kGO1hZrY3T-n4FZE99B74kJWceku6H7aQy3DZyvz4R-mQ0s9PVw1ufcQ8b6__F4wPU18AJoEFTCC9lD4iEl-1Fc1rV-giXHof1m717vxfIg1ZXFcN8Lf1yS393BnLik__IjYpEBmxrjF0PbdDGraZISg8Fiv91YvUbJV18EMmBb9Z1WKSPgmm-G8ChR-Jv7K171gB-jFxJvYB_sT_ZhFE_dlWMZhsYBaAoKwoGHMssZJDoU3CeJHWFkhUFLIsdr1_ddeBlqHoiKwHxDaTtVZrN6MeANIhigl8JaJPiO68-dbPnjvxpumhA7NPi_DJS4lU-YESj5pOvRmmyUKcUH779qLDKB5BC-8w37S_O0QPDwoa2nFBJsxFYqjhupWSR4O9Vp5hybOW_Sa7FOU3sGM9XVCIlaEJe-AHot9Be_bEDDlzkvnEFvlZDwMUhwTLVEdoaV6Rawcp297DrIIRUMOSkkVrR4Bep3P3Ugln5ddvyGlCC-k3nidYGmhaWybx7;thlang=en-US;NSC_NZUDD-443-WT=ffffffff090ecc1d45525d5f4f58455e445a4a42378b;], body:[DeviceID:597062, SystemSwitch:null, HeatSetpoint:null, CoolSetpoint:79, HeatNextPeriod:null, CoolNextPeriod:null, StatusHeat:2, StatusCool:2, FanMode:null, ThermostatUnits:F]]
09:43:22.416 am debugsetting cool setpoint to 79
09:43:22.413 am debugsetting heat setpoint to null
09:43:22.410 am debughttps://www.mytotalconnectcomfort.com/portal/Device/SubmitControlScreenChanges
09:43:22.408 am debugExecuting 'setStatus'
09:43:22.405 am debugcookies: ASP.NET_SessionId=dwpnk03421a5eo2zymmlk2kv;.ASPXAUTH_TRUEHOME=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;.ASPXAUTH_TRUEHOME_AT=ZpvJ0Pqtdb-fa1zzTc-Lj-lotdRfnZJZ79lGrnSMSGd2JmpLI7zKCXJydTg5sqLPdaRb_vp0D5xVPtI6KBKs6AaS-ouJMDd8TSmq2Ya-ETqMrhALGf0KGRi2Ug-h5cRxBkQ8mKMnN3fplovLrcD8wBAhGoyxAHMgjgtQeCvCzQ_xjvbR0R066IJSpnwP5G30PumWjRaGB9473140baY_IkfTdETV56TR2LEGTAppOssm9J8UnYdFQWnGJMZZ8lukEQEe5Ah1L6rOaADkWiKA5pOT6FqZCPQcH7TYoR1PXioSP5FF1o3JU2xRIvyBaN1fGHbGHotxn3F6haWxs1g-mphFz9H1VdyeBMAKXWVKvp5G7nbi1B4szWzeXLYDtb7RUZ6BwmrYO6JuXHqXKymWIPPf5s0U7rAxMGhdHgxYypi094pX4k8xheDOltGGGE8crBgEvXxrf9mSOOa8qGp7Mw7fHRIfLLwzAvRtF6PcWQ44V3nGxQZ6-oHh3hUdHKUOS8cWv8S-guWWoZlM4G7JESylZhlnaqMhdMXw-iUwVANxzqsrNQvT3CUndWTmADJYEgPlYhLpCLDJci_oief5D7yN8Rb8LznqYBGSdeP4f3b50E1X0Uq-h0-NTGNxjG6ju7DUW0MKOJu42rlBj-Y5OSruynBaMqBLH5LBBg3wCehnaCLG;.ASPXAUTH_TRUEHOME_RT=daCzZQAWmgEfMAD9-Srm-dHIsXqblZDuIYomwdGTNAiXuvaadJwKsLrz7Se1Rl9C9QUQ4xRok8yczTfFCfrxwDS6WIDDERiZO8yOBRGwI-xxkrVIXuKx2oENlamp53TYcKa2lJqGDnlfbn4hBdDYNNKFFEsfXJDqKIUFzCNDD4GhiBqez_kGO1hZrY3T-n4FZE99B74kJWceku6H7aQy3DZyvz4R-mQ0s9PVw1ufcQ8b6__F4wPU18AJoEFTCC9lD4iEl-1Fc1rV-giXHof1m717vxfIg1ZXFcN8Lf1yS393BnLik__IjYpEBmxrjF0PbdDGraZISg8Fiv91YvUbJV18EMmBb9Z1WKSPgmm-G8ChR-Jv7K171gB-jFxJvYB_sT_ZhFE_dlWMZhsYBaAoKwoGHMssZJDoU3CeJHWFkhUFLIsdr1_ddeBlqHoiKwHxDaTtVZrN6MeANIhigl8JaJPiO68-dbPnjvxpumhA7NPi_DJS4lU-YESj5pOvRmmyUKcUH779qLDKB5BC-8w37S_O0QPDwoa2nFBJsxFYqjhupWSR4O9Vp5hybOW_Sa7FOU3sGM9XVCIlaEJe-AHot9Be_bEDDlzkvnEFvlZDwMUhwTLVEdoaV6Rawcp297DrIIRUMOSkkVrR4Bep3P3Ugln5ddvyGlCC-k3nidYGmhaWybx7;thlang=en-US;NSC_NZUDD-443-WT=ffffffff090ecc1d45525d5f4f58455e445a4a42378b;
09:43:22.343 am debugAdding cookie to collection: NSC_NZUDD-443-WT=ffffffff090ecc1d45525d5f4f58455e445a4a42378b
09:43:22.339 am debugAdding cookie to collection: thlang=en-US
09:43:22.337 am debugAdding cookie to collection: .ASPXAUTH_TRUEHOME_RT=daCzZQAWmgEfMAD9-Srm-dHIsXqblZDuIYomwdGTNAiXuvaadJwKsLrz7Se1Rl9C9QUQ4xRok8yczTfFCfrxwDS6WIDDERiZO8yOBRGwI-xxkrVIXuKx2oENlamp53TYcKa2lJqGDnlfbn4hBdDYNNKFFEsfXJDqKIUFzCNDD4GhiBqez_kGO1hZrY3T-n4FZE99B74kJWceku6H7aQy3DZyvz4R-mQ0s9PVw1ufcQ8b6__F4wPU18AJoEFTCC9lD4iEl-1Fc1rV-giXHof1m717vxfIg1ZXFcN8Lf1yS393BnLik__IjYpEBmxrjF0PbdDGraZISg8Fiv91YvUbJV18EMmBb9Z1WKSPgmm-G8ChR-Jv7K171gB-jFxJvYB_sT_ZhFE_dlWMZhsYBaAoKwoGHMssZJDoU3CeJHWFkhUFLIsdr1_ddeBlqHoiKwHxDaTtVZrN6MeANIhigl8JaJPiO68-dbPnjvxpumhA7NPi_DJS4lU-YESj5pOvRmmyUKcUH779qLDKB5BC-8w37S_O0QPDwoa2nFBJsxFYqjhupWSR4O9Vp5hybOW_Sa7FOU3sGM9XVCIlaEJe-AHot9Be_bEDDlzkvnEFvlZDwMUhwTLVEdoaV6Rawcp297DrIIRUMOSkkVrR4Bep3P3Ugln5ddvyGlCC-k3nidYGmhaWybx7
09:43:22.332 am debugAdding cookie to collection: .ASPXAUTH_TRUEHOME_AT=ZpvJ0Pqtdb-fa1zzTc-Lj-lotdRfnZJZ79lGrnSMSGd2JmpLI7zKCXJydTg5sqLPdaRb_vp0D5xVPtI6KBKs6AaS-ouJMDd8TSmq2Ya-ETqMrhALGf0KGRi2Ug-h5cRxBkQ8mKMnN3fplovLrcD8wBAhGoyxAHMgjgtQeCvCzQ_xjvbR0R066IJSpnwP5G30PumWjRaGB9473140baY_IkfTdETV56TR2LEGTAppOssm9J8UnYdFQWnGJMZZ8lukEQEe5Ah1L6rOaADkWiKA5pOT6FqZCPQcH7TYoR1PXioSP5FF1o3JU2xRIvyBaN1fGHbGHotxn3F6haWxs1g-mphFz9H1VdyeBMAKXWVKvp5G7nbi1B4szWzeXLYDtb7RUZ6BwmrYO6JuXHqXKymWIPPf5s0U7rAxMGhdHgxYypi094pX4k8xheDOltGGGE8crBgEvXxrf9mSOOa8qGp7Mw7fHRIfLLwzAvRtF6PcWQ44V3nGxQZ6-oHh3hUdHKUOS8cWv8S-guWWoZlM4G7JESylZhlnaqMhdMXw-iUwVANxzqsrNQvT3CUndWTmADJYEgPlYhLpCLDJci_oief5D7yN8Rb8LznqYBGSdeP4f3b50E1X0Uq-h0-NTGNxjG6ju7DUW0MKOJu42rlBj-Y5OSruynBaMqBLH5LBBg3wCehnaCLG
09:43:22.328 am debugAdding cookie to collection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
09:43:22.315 am debugAdding cookie to collection: ASP.NET_SessionId=dwpnk03421a5eo2zymmlk2kv
09:43:22.311 am debuggroovyx.net.http.HttpResponseDecorator$HeadersDecorator@660a6b33
09:43:22.301 am debugRequest was successful, 302
09:43:21.621 am infoExecuting 'login'

Thanks for any help or suggestions!

Yes, that's what my logs looked like too but now I don't poll very often 1) to reduce the errors, and 2) because I simply don't do much with the device. Every 3 months or so, I toggle Heat --> off --> Cool --> off --> Heat. More or less corresponding to Winter --> Spring --> Summer -- > Fall --> Winter

I have debugging off too, but at every hour:

dev:1212019-03-30 07:36:38.831 am infoSet Fan operating State to: On
dev:1212019-03-30 07:36:38.829 am infoSet operating State to: Heating
dev:1212019-03-30 07:36:37.572 am infoExecuting 'login'
dev:1212019-03-30 07:36:37.518 am infoin poll: 120
dev:1212019-03-30 06:36:38.840 am infoSet Fan operating State to: Idle
dev:1212019-03-30 06:36:38.837 am infoSet operating State to: Idle
dev:1212019-03-30 06:36:37.522 am infoExecuting 'login'
dev:1212019-03-30 06:36:37.486 am infoin poll: 120
dev:1212019-03-30 05:36:39.135 am infoSet Fan operating State to: Idle
dev:1212019-03-30 05:36:39.132 am infoSet operating State to: Idle
dev:1212019-03-30 05:36:37.565 am infoExecuting 'login'
dev:1212019-03-30 05:36:37.462 am infoin poll: 120
dev:1212019-03-30 04:36:39.581 am infoSet Fan operating State to: Idle
dev:1212019-03-30 04:36:39.579 am infoSet operating State to: Idle
dev:1212019-03-30 04:36:37.507 am infoExecuting 'login'
dev:1212019-03-30 04:36:37.426 am infoin poll: 120

I'm not seeing the Unauthorized error.

It's been a while since I worked on that driver but I would set the poll time to minimum, in order to test and I'd see Unauthorized a lot. (Editing the code and saving causes an instant poll and often, an instant Unauthorized.)

Does anyone here use the Honeywell T6 Pro Zwave thermostat?
Any issues?
https://www.aartech.ca/lyric-t6-pro-zwave-thermostat-th6320zw2003?gclid=CjwKCAjw-ZvlBRBbEiwANw9UWk276nRPYUthfTVjzjFHhASpLZlv3GkiLN_bQBZ2Z8f2xDPjdyjUxhoCSycQAvD_BwE

I have the Lyric T5 thermostat. I think the difference between the T5 and T6 is that the T6 was a dealer installed device and the T5 was a consumer available device. As far as I know both the T5 and T6 devices are both cloud based WiFi devices. If you look at the upper right corner of the picture you can see the WiFi symbol.

The T6 Pro has a Zwave Plus Option.

I have never seen any reference to the Lyric T series and Zwave and I was at the Honeywell plant involved with the App beta. It took some looking to find it. Thanks.

I found a DH on the ST forums so . . .

AHA!
So, can we have a candid comment about the quality/capabilities/etc. of the T6 Pro?
(from an insider, without giving out any industrial secrets)

I don't know if the WiFi and Zwave devices can compare. The interfaces look alike and I would assume they program at the device in a similar way. Beyond that, the Zwave device would be totally controlled through the HE hub. As it is now, I have no access to the thermostat through HE. My only control is through the app and Alexa and I so seldom use the app. It is nice to have Alexa to turn up the heat on cold mornings when I decide to get up early.
I will say, I am very tempted to get one of them and replace my T5. I like the look of the device, which I don't think I could say of any of the Zwave devices I have looked at.

I know I'm a bit late on this question, but I just helped a friend I converted to Hubitat add a Honeywell T6 Pro to his system. It mostly works fine, but Google Home doesn't always like to control it (seems to be better lately)--a minor problem--but will also occasionally send about 10 current temperature reports per second for minutes at a time, flooding the hub logs, and presumably not doing the Z-Wave network any favors--presumably a major problem, though it doesn't actually seem to be causing any real problems. Anyone else noticed this? Tempted to try porting the ST driver, though unless the driver is generating spurious events it seems far more likely to be an issue with the device itself.

Do you think you could provide a little more information (i.e., a how-to) on you setup? I have an ecobee3 and would like to use my comfort settings. But, I'm pretty new to HE (and home automation in general) and am still finding my way around.

Thanks!

I won’t be by my hub until next week so it might be hard to create any how to.

But off the top of my head you can install the ifttt webhook driver below, and then in ifttt setup some rules that will activate a comfort setting if the webhook is triggered. This way you have mapped a virtual device to a comfort setting using ifttt.

Hopefully that helps. It shouldn’t be too hard.

Thanks! I'll give it a shot!

Cheers!