Hub Mesh Physical Off Not Triggering App (RM-Legacy or 5)

[rob9]

I have a GE/Jasco dimmer outlet and had it set to trigger a rule on "Physical off".

I had an Legacy Rule that wasn't working--so I created an identical RM-V rule app:

RM-V

RM-Legacy

With the Legacy App "X" disabled so only the RM-V app was active, I turned the light off physically:

I can see in the logs where that is detected (shows physical off in the logs and device events--but there's nothing in the logs indicating the RM app should be triggering.

I tried many times with both the legacy and the new RM app--I'm never able to make this rule trigger from the "physical off" event.

This is a mesh-connected device. On the hub it connects to directly:

And on the hub with the apps the mesh-device shows:

From the RM-V app/rule:

Thoughts?

Thanks!

[bravenel]

@rob9

This is a mesh-connected device. On the hub it connects to directly:

Mesh connected devices don't report physical events such that this would work. Perhaps they should, not sure. Below you can see two events for a mesh connected device, and while the description text indicates what the type of the event was on the source hub, you can see that the actual event type is blank.

[rob9]

Interesting. Thanks.

Guess until they can do that--I need to look at alternatives.

Thanks!

[gopher.ny]

Looking into it. This is going to get fixed, although the usual "no timeline promises" policy applies.

[gopher.ny]

Event type should work right in hub mesh with 2.2.8.151 and above.

[rob9]

W00t! Thanks! Works like a champ now!