Does Pi-Hole break HE, HPO, WebCore etc

This driver is just a switch so my Routines Dashboard has a simple tile added to toggle the Pi-Hole filtering. I had no where else to put it. Boring. :wink:
I wish I could have the Pi-Hole Dash added to my HE Dashboard, that would be interesting. The screenshot above is from Pi-Hole itself.
I did use the one you reference but I picked this one due to it's newer build date.

The iOS app Pi-Hole Remote is also a great option to quickly access Pi-Hole to turn blocking on/off. I use a widget on my Home Screen.

The in-app purchase for additional features is optional but worth it IMO.

Thanks for the info.
I can remote into my Dashboards so I can just hit the tile to Enable/Disable for now.
I will probably only need it when friends look after the house and complain of 'It's not like this at home on my Netflix, GoogleTV etc.". :slight_smile:
Seem unobtrusive so far.

It's best to have at least 2 instances of Pi-hole on 2 separate machine and multiple dns providers if you have a busy house with family members. This will save you tons of headache when Pi-hole machine is down. I switched over to Adguard Home 2 years ago and they are very similar. I find Pi-hole is a little harder to track down the issue when a site is not working. Maybe the newer Pi-hole is better at this.
I have 3 instances of Adguard running. One on Proxmox, Home Assistant and on a Pi since it was doing nothing other than monitoring my 3D printer. 2 years without skipping a beat.

There are only 2 adults (wife would disagree) in the house so not a lot of traffic.
I have the latest PI-Hole and once I went to WSL 2 all worked fine.
I have a spare NUC so if it becomes an issue I can install Linux on that.
So far Docker is doing fine, no resource use to speak of.

I think @Navat604 was referring more to the possibility of your Pi-Hole instance being down (for any of a variety of possible reasons), thus breaking DNS resolution for clients at home (and therefore, internet connectivity).

Setting up more than one pi-hole can help avoid downtime so that clients can still reach a working DNS server even if one instance of pi-hole goes down.

Learned this a few weeks after installing Pi-Hole on my NAS, was rebooting the NAS with a trial Unraid licence (that needs internet to validate until the real licence is purchased). Since it could not find a working DNS as it would not start the docker containers, I could not authenticate. Had to go in my Omada controller and add 1.1.1.1 as the secondary DNS on it, rebooted the NAS and all went well. Not sure I would add a second Pi-Hole instance as backup, fo rthe few times the NAS or container is down during backups, I'll live with it as it was a few months back :wink:

Yeah, I knew he was going for redundancy.
I think I can just change my secondary router DNS to Google or Cloudflare as a failover if the primary (Pi) is down.
No blocking but then I'm not too concerned; my paranoia is just kicking in after 45 years of IT. :wink:
I remember when a virus kept you home from work not closed it. :rofl:

But where’s the fun in that?

Two pi-holes = 2x the opportunity for me to break DNS at home!

2 Likes

Ironically, Mark-the-knife, my wife knows where I keep the Japanese knives.
At least the doctor gave me a shot first. :wink:

100% I feel like this is true with my two HE's and the RPI I have running.
My wife is paranoid something is going to happen to me and the "house will stop working". lol

2 Likes

My wife's concern is entropy. It will slowly become the house from hell. All will be good until the battery devices randomly go on a walk-about.

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.