I would go with the Aeotec only for the reason that I like applications that have full ground and neutral connections. Not saying the dewenwils wouldn’t work though.
I had an electrician install the Dewenwils over a year ago to control power to a garage heater unit that drives about 3500W. The driver is “Universal Z-Wave switch”. Pairing was easy and it works fine. The distance to my hub is about 40 feet, through at least four walls (2 x 4 drywall construction).
I don’t trigger it much so it occasionally shows up as “inactive“ in some of my device monitoring apps, so I created a rule that runs daily at 5 AM that simply runs this custom action:
Thanks - I wasn’t sure if it would work with the generic driver
My use case is similar - it will always be “on” and the Aqualogic pool controller will operate as it does now. If there is a power outage, I want to shut the pool off (except if freeze guard needs to run and I have an outdoor temperature sensor for that).