I am using a single Geofence right now. I have not tried more than one.
OK, well I have two setup on my hubby's phone and three on mine. I have re-installed Maker API and redid all the URLs and they tested ok. I will just have to wait and see if the Geofence locations work.
1 Like
So, I re-installed the Maker API and redid the URL's in Locative and all seems to be working now! I have three locations setup for myself and two for my hubby and they seem to all be giving me notices via Pushover. Working well right now!
1 Like
Glad to hear the good news! I appreciate you testing the multiple geofence locations and reporting back.
It actually seems to work pretty well! I don't notice any battery drain on the iphones and setting up some simple RM apps to notify whomever I want to notify works well. In ST you couldn't pick who could get the notifications.
Here is my list of methods I have seen people use to achieve Presence Detection with Hubitat. This might help you if you'd like to create something new. Options are a good thing! 
1 Like
Hehe. I see that I'm treading on well-worn paths. I can also add to your list the Nest Presence service, if you happen to have Nest thermostats.
For my own personal use, the nest one is fine, or I can (currently) pull from the ST presence service. The only real reason I waded in at all was the whole 'local vs cloud' debate - and I'm quite enjoying having to digest fewer 3rd party services at the moment.
-- Jules
@ogiewon I submit for healthy debate that the list really has two categories; Location (Geolocation) and Presence (two devices connecting in a local short-range network)
In my mind, I’ve always categorized Geolocation as anything cellular based that has a minimum range of 400ft (Because that’s the lowest detection range I’ve seen for something cellular based), and call Location for shorthand, as do the phone manufacturers.
For anything Zigbee, Bluetooth or WiFi, I have always considered it to be Presence because it uses short distance radio waves that only indicate a users presence when a device connects to a local transmitter or mesh network, not via triangulation.
I do not consider anything the detects a user motion to be presence detection, because the object or person must continue to move for detection to remain active.
How does everyone else see this distinction, or do you? I think it's important, at least in creating automations, that there is some kind of understanding and distinction of the two types, how they react and how they should be used together. Otherwise we start wondering things like "Why did [all] my lights suddenly turn on" when our phones or devices briefly lose and regain the local connection that is triggering presence.
Oh, and to add to that nice list you created, there are two types of IFTTT detection. One is Geolocation using triangulation of your phone to the cell towers, and the other is and IFTTT trigger when your phone connects or disconnects from supported WiFI devices. This is what I use for "Presence" with our phones and my TP-Link Deco M5 mesh WiFi.
Also, just to confirm, I'm one of the users that has the Homebridge/HomeKit "Location" service working with HE. Requirements are a node.js server to run Homebridge, an iOS device obviously, and either an Apple TV 4 or later, or an always on iPad that can run the latest iOS. I think @csteele is also using this method if I'm not mistaken.
1 Like
This list does help but unfortunately most of these options require the use of IOS, which I do not use or another hub running like ST. The virtual presence switch is probably something I will look into. I do have Iris Fobs as presence which are in both cars, but I am finding there can be long delays, sometimes even minutes until it reconnects to HE. This is even with the garage being under the house and a Iris Plug directly above the garage to repeat the signal.
The problem with any WiFi or Zigbee/Z-wave solution is you generally need to be very close to the house before it will work. I have light that turn on at night based on presence and by the time these devices would trigger the light its too late.
I tried this myself, and it's a shame there's apparently no way to make it work without turning on the entire "Share My Location" feature (also used for Find My Friends and whatnot). I'd rather just give the Home app "Always" access to my location like Reminders and other apps where background location is useful can do and have that be the "trigger." I appreciate reading about options you and a couple others have posted about--I thought this was going to be the one (low battery consumption, native to the OS), but I guess I'll have to read about the other options again. This makes them easy to find, at least.
2 Likes
Maybe an external WiFi AP may be the only way to get the signal far enough, but even then it depends on a lot of factors.
I think the biggest problem is not presence itself, its reliable detection, even with Life360 sometimes it does not work for various reasons.
Yea I feel like an iOS expert but struggled with getting this working. Maybe that was my problem.
I don't want that noise enabled...
Yep, I struggled too until I read Apple's instructions: Create scenes and automations - Apple Support
Unlike regular location access, the Home app won't prompt you to enable this feature if it it isn't already. The location-based automation just won't work.
1 Like
Is that true? I am using iOS for presence and it's been perfect for a couple years now, ST last year and Hubitat this year... both via Homebridge.
In iOS Settings: Privacy:Location Services:Share My Location:
That section is setting which device that has your name/ID attached, will be authoritative as you. Which device do you consider "yours" vs a family member that is also using your Apple ID. It allows you to set which
Also in iOS Settings: Privacy:Location Services: is a list of apps that would love to use your location. Me, I turn them all off (never) except a few set to "While using" -- none of mine are set to Always. The Home app is in the list and it's set to "while using the app" and it's interesting to note that Apple does not offer the Aways option for this app. Maps are also set to "while using" because of course they don't work well without.
In other words, I'm interpreting "Share My Location" differently.
1 Like
Just looking at my ping logs from last night. Each of our phones was offline at one point for at least 10 minutes. The range was from seconds to 10 minutes when pinging every 5 seconds.
This is on an iphone 7+ and 8+.
Been doing this a long time. It sucks that my system won't arm until I'm gone for at least 15 minutes, but its nice that its instant when I arrive home.
I just think "there must be a better way"
Now play this in your mind with Kevin O'leary voice:)
Hmmm? - Only 2 of the 11 options I listed are iOS only (Locative and Homekit). Only 1 requires ST.
I will say that my combination of HomeKit location and WiFi presence always works, but there is a speed lag sometimes when my phone doesn't connect to WiFi right away. I'm using an iPhone 6, so maybe the slower processor or outdated WiFi components are the issue. I'm just at the front door entering the code before it connect to WiFi on occasion. Other times, I'm not up my walk yet and the door unlocks.
Wondering that too. I turned most of this off for the screen shot here, but it looks to me like you could just enable HomeKit if you wanted.
You can go much smaller than 400ft with Geolocation. A good system also allows multiple geofence methods not just a circle. It depends on the device being used. Even with some cell phones you can go very small...
https://forums.simplextech.net/threads/how-to-use-in-homeseer.11/post-16
One user in testing setup a 10ft geofence inside their home. It worked. YMMV as always.
