Alternatives to Sinopé water valve?

I am replacing my Fortrezz WaterCop and had been planning on getting this:

Sedna Secondary Water Valve – Sinopé Technologies

However, the tariff is nearly $100, so I want to see if there were any similar devices that people like. I do not want anything that turns a ball valve, using the pipe as leverage. Ideally, there would be a PEX fitting for it.

whats wrong tith the water cop that goes inline.. i have had one for years and its rock solid and a good repeater to boot.. pricy though

i also have one of these.. again works well.

It never was totally satisfactory, especially the 2012 one that had an ancient Z-Wave implementation in it. I bought a 2019 one that solved that problem (mostly, still not ZWave+) but it is getting sluggish. I do exercise it weekly, but it still is iffy about whether it will turn it all the way. My "turn water off" procedure involves turning it off, and after 10 seconds, power cycle the Watercop, then repeat .. like four times. Eventually it gets closed, but I'd rather have something that is more certain.

Here's a few choices that are similar to the watercop.

https://www.supplyhouse.com/Rusco-3-4-SBV-Z-3-4-Smart-Ball-Valve-ZigBee

Looks like you'd have to connect a relay to it? That's in the same price ballpack as the Sinope with tariff, and it is already ZigBee 3.0 so it would be ready to go.

The Bulldog looks like it is a valve turner rather than self-contained valve.

The Ezlo looked promising, but it would require extra fittings for 34/" PEX or NPT. Also, seems it is only sold in a two-pack?

I just went to the Ezlo web site to look at the details of that water valve. They have it on their site for the same price, and no mention of it being a '2 Pack'. My guess is that the listing is incorrect on the Amazon site.

I believe you are right. Also on their website it has a 3/4" NPT fitting.

But the price is still comparable to the Sinope (even with the $92 tariff). I have a Sinope switch for my well pump and was pretty impressed with it, so I will just hold my nose and pay the $330 for the Sinope.

I appreciate all the suggestions.

Please report back on how your experience with the Sinope Zigbee valve. I have zero Z-Wave devices, so I am interested in hearing how well it works for you. I have a 1" copper water main, so the price would be a little more than yours.

Any clue if Hubitat's Sinope driver supports the optional Sinope water flow meter? That would be nice information to have... :thinking: I wonder if @mike.maxwell might want to chime in? I am not even sure if the Zigbee "secondary" water valves even support the optional flow sensor....???

Interestingly, Ezlo is the company that acquired Fortrezz. In a YouTube video from CES 2022, they showed their "current model" (Fortrezz) and new model (Ezlo). If the Ezlo used the same fitting (square with four holes) as the Fortrezz, that would be ideal. But the Ezlo fitting is round; not at all drop-in compatible.

I've had a Sinope Zigbee VA4220 valve since 2022, along with the water flowmeter.

There are no issues with instantaneous measurements, but cumulative measurements aren't possible (which can only be done through their GT hub), so I track them differently.

The only issue I’ve encountered is that sometimes, when the flow drops to zero, it stays at its last instantaneous value. I solved the problem with a simple monitoring rule.

Yes the valve works with the flow meter the flow meter was supported at least theee years ago, I use one of the valves to control my shops air supply from the shops compressor

If you feel adventurous, try this driver.

What else does it offer? And why adventurous?

Both things you mentioned - volume and the flow rate zero fix (and a few more minor features not exposed by the system driver).

'cause I wrote it :wink: but it's been in use for over three years now. Let me know.

FWIW I am using a Zooz Zen16 with my Watercop. I don’t use the Watercop zwave module any longer and the Zen16 relays will actuate the valve and control the power to the water cop.

I just installed it, so I'm going to test it out. What interests me is the total volume consumption. I'll be able to compare it with a pulse meter that I installed as a backup. I'm curious to see how it turns out. Thanks!

I'm currently testing the driver. Why doesn't the flow reset to zero when I close the valve (same issue as with the Hubitat driver)?

OK, it resets to (almost) zero after 1 minute (after refresh button hit). Is this determined by the poll?

Update: I ran an initial test of total water consumption.

My Sinope shows 100.6 liters, and my DLJ (an analog gauge that reads in gallons) shows approximately 110 liters, but the reading is less accurate.

I’ll check over a longer period, but I think the Sinope should be much more accurate.

Suggest we move the driver conversation here.