Who has a HIGHLY RELIABLE Zigbee network and what repeaters are you using?

Remove any Aqara garbage that you have on your mesh. Seems like half the problems with Zigbee involve Aqara devices.

My mesh is rock solid now and I use a mix of Sonoff, Third Reality, generic peanut plugs, and a few Tuya power strips. All my bulbs are Sengled which do not act as repeaters.

1 Like

3000 sq ft house, plus detached garage 100ft away here.

48 Zigbee devices here. No zwave. Had issues with 1 aqara motion sensor device, which was solved by adding a few IKEA tradfri in the mix.

I first built my network in order to save on utility bill, so the backbone of my mesh is all of my thermostats (10 of them) are Zigbee, as well as some light switches, and all of the big power utility (water heater, garage heater, pool heater, pool pump, EV charger).

1 Like

Never had any Aqara, saw too many issues in others posts. I had 6 x Sonoff S31 Lite and the versions I had were terrible, see my long post on this from last year.

That is exactly the same as my scenario but they would be non responsive after a few weeks but I wouldn't know it until my automations would fail to run. I'm guessing we have different firmware.

On the plus side - window and motion sensors are smaller than other makes, inexpensive (well, maybe not as much these days) and best of all insane battery life (18 months - 2 years).

Each his own but many of us run them very well once you understand the hardware limitations and are prepared to work around them.

Price is great. Would only let me order 2 for some reason but it will be enough to test with and I'll be able to see how they perform with my Xbee. If they pan out I'll get a few more and hopefully I can put two hubs back into one if the Zigbee mesh is reliable.

Thanks for the recommendation. I ordered a couple tonight to test with.

1 Like

I've been using a single outlet in each room - sure I have repeaters that came after the fact but no troubles!
Seedan, CMars, DoGain - all are based on the same chips - show up as eWeLink- zig 3.0 and solid as stone. I turned off Zwave a long time ago - don't use BT or Wifi either. Helps that I modded the driver from markus to my needs :slight_smile:

My Zig3.0 :slight_smile:

1 Like

Thanks for sharing. What kind of square footage are you covering? If it's a typical house you must have a couple in every room and a very dense mesh?

When you have two of the eWeLink devices in the same room what kind of link quality numbers are you getting on the connection between the two.

Here is mine including nodes at the moment but looking to improve the mesh.

Hey! This isn’t really on the same topic, but I am looking for a Zigbee or Z-Wave power strip that doesn’t cost $70 like Zooz. Which power strip did you end up going with and which driver do you use it with?

Anyone reading this thread obviously has questions\concerns about their Zigbee network and will likely find this link helpful as it lets you get the same information you get from using an XBEE, but on a per repeater basis.

For example:


The above data is formatted with TIle Builder Advanced but is also available within the driver.

I will be very curious to see if someone with a Sonoff S31 tries this out and reports back what their LQI values are. The Sonoff S31's poor performance were the whole reason I opened this thread in the first place.

I'm using the 2nd post in the above thread to keep compatibility information so hopefully people will submit info from the most common devices.

2 Likes

I should add that I did eventually add 4 x Tuya USB mini-repeaters along with my 2 x Sylvania and 1 x XBee and went back to all my Zigbee devices on one hub and is has been very stable.

2 Likes

Not many zigbee devices, but they are all battery powered, so no repeaters. All paired direct to hub. I hit reliability issues when I add repeaters (plugs), so everything line powered is Z-Wave for me.

I think there are a lot of crap plugs out there. For a while I was doing what you are, except I added a second hub for extra coverage.

1 Like

Thing is, most all line powered devices are repeaters. So, if you want to do stuff, like switch electrical loads, you'll be adding repeaters.

Indeed. Ironically, adding repeaters should strengthen the mesh and make it more resilient. But if they are low quality devices, the exact opposite happens. That is partly why I went with the dedicated Mini USB repeaters.

Hopefully with this new driver we can gather some information on the relative strengths of different plugs and all make more informed choices.

2 Likes

Probably white noise at this point, but I’ll share my experience.

I have three rules:

  1. No lightbulbs on a network with other end devices. Sengled are the only exception, but I don’t have any in use anymore. My smart bulbs are all Hue on their own Zigbee network running off of a Hue Bridge.

  2. I always test a repeater and see how it works out. I don’t just throw them in. If I experience reliability problems I try moving them, but if that doesn’t work they’re gone.

  3. I don’t connect Xiaomi and IKEA devices on anything but my ConBee2 controller running on HA. I get it, some people have success with them on Hubitat. I didn’t, and I’ve tried many times over the years when someone came along and said I’ve now written the perfect driver and it’s all going to work great now. It never has for me, and it’s a lot of stress for me and the family when things are not functioning properly. The way I have it now works perfect, so I’ve no desire to change it.

Here are my two network maps for Hubitat and HA with the ConBee 2. All of the repeating on Hubitat you’ll notice Is via my Sinope thermostats. That’s just a nice side effect of a choice I made for my electrically heated home. One thing to note is that one of the devices on the Hubitat network map named Air Handler is an IKEA outlet and nothing on my Hubitat Zigbee network wants to use it as a repeater. Whereas the ConBee2 on HA is using one of them to repeat. The point being that you just don’t know exactly what’s going to work until you try, move things around if they’re not working well, and switch them out to get the best combination. I’m very glad that the Sinope have turned out to be such good repeaters for Hubitat.


1 Like

C-8 Hub 2.3.6.146 with Z-Wave turned off. Zigbee on Channel 20 with Power Level 8.
45 Zigbee devices.
2 Unifi AP-AC-Pro Access Points with Channels set to Auto.
1 Unifi AP-BeaconHD with Channels set to Auto.
45 neighboring WiFi devices detected.
7 repeater devices (4 SmartThings/Centralite outlets, 3 Smartenit relays hard-wired to fans). 1 Smartenit relay (ceiiling fan) routes for 4 devices, 1 Smartenit relay (ceiling fan) routes for 8 devices, 1 Smartenit relay (attic exhaust fan) routes for 1 device. 2 of the outlets route for 4 devices each, 1 outlet routes for 3 devices and one routes for 1 device.
These routing devices are some of the oldest Zigbee devices I own.
Routing shifts a bit over time but about half of the devices are consistently directly connected.

1 Like

I have also found these to be excellent. With both Hubitat and zigbee2mqtt.

3 Likes

With the new zigbee map app, i see that my leviton plug in dimmer is a beast. Link quality above 250 with almost all of my network despite some distance and obstacles. Everything else (Third reality, sonoff, sengled) hovers below 100.