Hi rwclements,
Sounds like you’ve made a big effort to use Aqara. I understand as they are very pleasing to the eye compared to alternatives as you mentioned.
I found motion sensor and door contacts would work fine reporting motion and doors opening and closing until you attached an automation to them. Once an automation was attached to a device they would stop reporting motion/door opening etc.
I tried creating automations through HomeBridge not Hubitat and they worked fine although I have had some stop working occasionally and had to delete and reinstall them.
Problem solving is one of the aspects of home automation I enjoy to a point and as you describe it maybe time to resign Aqara to the back of the cupboard until they improve.
I’ve enjoyed sharing this experience so I don’t feel I’m the only one having problems. It’s easy to jump to the conclusion it’s Hubitat short comings but clearly getting all the different third parties devices to work correctly with Hubitat is not a realistic proposition. I’ve played with most of the major home automation platforms and Hubitat is my favourite.
Regards, Richard.