I recently swapped two outlets: one generic zigbee outlet (GE brand), and one Third Reality outlet. Now, for some reason, they don't report the right thing... The GE one reports the right power, but the wrong state (always off, even though I toggle it on and off). MakerAPI for the GE one was reporting the power of the 3R one until I rebooted the hub, while it was reporting the power of the GE one for the 3R one. That seems to have fixed the power reporting, but not the switch reporting (the GE one still reports as being off despite being on, even if I toggle it manually or through the hub).
If so, the respective "Current States" are probably wacked -- they sometimes (often? never?) aren't purged/reset correctly during a swap.
You can change the Device Type to plain "Device" and use its option to clear all states (something like that - I'm going from memory here) and then change back to correct driver - that should help "reset" the states.
I recently swapped several devices out, and in all cases the new device didn’t seem to be working until I hit save device. These were contact sensors. Once I hit save, they started responding.