Losing patience with hubitat slowness

Every 2-3 days I have to reboot my hub because it slows to a crawl. I'm talking 30 sec response times between motion and light events. and 30+ second page loads of the UI. A reboot fixes me up for another 2-3 days, but soon enough i'm right back where I was. Interestingly, performance doesn't seem to degrade over time, it seems more event based- it was fast, then its slow. Period.

I've pared down all f my apps so that I'm running:

One RM rule.
25 or so groups
168 z-wave and zigbee devices

Amazon Echo Skill
HSM
Hue Bridge
Life360
MQTT app

That's it. No other processing on hubitat.

I suppose my issue could be with Kevin's MQTT beta app, but it seems to me that other's are having similar issues who aren't running MQTT. Is there any fix on the horizon, or even a clue as to what's going on?

As a shameless plug, have you tried Rootin’ Tootin’ Self Rebootin’?

It will detect slowdown and automatically reboot.

1 Like

Interesting. The one problem I'd have with that is that after reboot I have to re-run the MQTT device discovery to make all of my devices show up to Home Assistant. Looks cool though. May give it a shot. How are you detecting slowness?

I know its not a solution, but I use the following. Its another rebooter option

Two methods.

  1. Schedules an event, and checks how long that event takes to respond.
  2. Tests for an error reading a value, which is indicative of a 500 error

I just do something like this from linux to reboot. I wonder if I can do something similar to detect slowness? That still leaves me with my MQTT discovery problem though... and the issue where my garage door tends to want to open when I do the hub reboot, which is why I like to do it by hand right now.

#!/bin/bash
curl -k -c /home/bill/hubitat-cookie  -d username=reboot -d password=reboot https://192.168.2.2/login
sleep 5
curl -k -sb /home/bill/hubitat-cookie -X POST https://192.168.2.2/hub/reboot

They should remain there , visible in HA . Have you set this ?

image

The MQTT app will restart itself on reboot and once it posts that it is 'ready' in the homie/hubname/$state topic HA will update it's devices from 'unavailable' to functional

You could just schedule daily reboots. This is how I'm doing it for now, until I have time to figure out what device on my system is causing the issue. There's two different ways shown in this thread.

Sorry to ask this, but can you give a list of what devices you have and how many of them?

What do you have controlling your lights? You say you only have

You don't mention motion lighting so what is controlling your lights? Are you doing it with Node-Red or HA or some other external system through MQTT?

Everything is controlled by appdaemon through HA, rather than directly through MQTT.

How do you have HA connected to Hubitat? Through MQTT?

Hmm... I have "remember" on. Maybe I'm not waiting long enough for it to get to ready. Will test this afternoon.

@Ryan780 correct.

Okay...so, if your control is coming from HA, have you considered that that might be the point that the slowness is occurring?

I have, and it isn't.

First of all the slowness happens with the echo skill too.

Secondly, I can follow a given event through all of my logging (I don't have an example in front of me right now because everything is working) and I can see that the slowness exists between appdaemon sending the command and hubitat executing it. It's not entirely clear that this isn't in mosquitto or MQTT app, but if I reboot hubitat and not mosquitto it goes away.

Also I was having issues like this before using Kevin's MQTT app.

Next thing is commands executed out of appdaemon to non-hubitat devices continue to perform as usual.

Final piece of evidence pointing at hubitat is how slow the web interface gets too.

@frits here's the device list:

[Alarm Clock
(Alarm Clock)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/546) Virtual Dimmer System alrm01 2020-03-14 12:25:55 AM PDT
[alexa-hotwater
(alexa-hotwater)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1715) Virtual Dimmer System d97b7acf-6d9f-4fc9-a… 2020-03-13 9:14:45 AM PDT
[alexa-mode
(alexa-mode)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1648) Virtual Dimmer System 9216feeb-4e9d-4578-b… 2020-03-14 7:30:12 AM PDT
[All Lights
(All Lights Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1606) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1663 2020-03-14 8:57:26 AM PDT
[Attic 1
(hueBridgeBulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/965) hueBridgeBulb System 999/8 2020-03-09 9:45:11 PM PDT
[Attic 2
(Generic Zigbee CT Bulb (dev))
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/457) Generic Zigbee CT Bulb (dev) System D942

B0CE18140302E055 2020-03-13 5:50:40 PM PDT
[Attic Hold
(Attic Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1007) Virtual Dimmer System 9d6f350f-b99e-4854-b… 2020-03-13 3:48:18 PM PDT
[Attic Lights
(Attic Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1600) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1657 2020-03-14 12:06:09 AM PDT
[Barbeque Lights
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/356) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 3F 2020-03-09 8:04:38 PM PDT
[Basement East
(hueBridgeBulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/966) hueBridgeBulb System 999/3 2020-03-13 3:48:23 PM PDT
[Basement Followers
(Basement Followers)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1597) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1654 2020-03-14 8:54:32 AM PDT
[Basement Hold
(Basement Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/779) Virtual Dimmer System lo09 2020-03-14 8:54:38 AM PDT
[Basement Lights
(Basement Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1596) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1653 2020-03-14 8:54:33 AM PDT
[Basement North
(hueBridgeBulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/967) hueBridgeBulb System 999/5 2020-03-14 8:54:31 AM PDT
[Basement Stairs
(hueBridgeBulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/964) hueBridgeBulb System 999/2

000D6F000CA6F293 2020-03-14 8:54:31 AM PDT
[Basement West
(hueBridgeBulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/971) hueBridgeBulb System 999/1 2020-03-14 8:54:31 AM PDT
[Bathroom Ceiling Light
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/112) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 0A 2020-03-14 8:37:09 AM PDT
[Bathroom Fan
(Generic Z-Wave Switch)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/122) Generic Z-Wave Switch System 0C 2020-03-14 12:08:10 AM PDT
[Bathroom Hold
(Bathroom Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/777) Virtual Dimmer System lo07 2020-03-14 8:37:06 AM PDT
[Beam East
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/259) Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor System 30 2020-01-30 12:27:14 AM PST
[Beam Front
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/336) Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor System 3C 2020-03-14 5:55:23 AM PDT
[Beam Rear
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/327) Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor System 38 2020-03-14 8:59:00 AM PDT
[Bedroom Closet
(Generic Zigbee Bulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/513) Generic Zigbee Bulb System 9AE9

B0CE18140317CC45 2020-03-13 5:50:39 PM PDT
[Bedroom Closet Sensor
(Window Bathroom)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/176) SmartSense Multi Sensor V4 System 445D

000D6F000BBE78D8 2020-03-14 8:51:41 AM PDT
[Bedroom Diffuser
(Generic Zigbee Outlet)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/118) Generic Zigbee Outlet System B49F

000D6F000CA4F1A8 2020-03-14 4:12:03 AM PDT
[Bedroom Diffuser Repeater
(Generic Z-Wave Repeater)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/359) Iris Z-Wave Repeater User 40 2020-03-14 8:41:02 AM PDT
[Bedroom Hold
(Bedroom Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/776) Virtual Dimmer System lo06 2020-03-14 8:57:23 AM PDT
[Bedroom Light
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/111) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 08 2020-03-14 8:57:25 AM PDT
[Bedroom Lights
(Bedroom Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1595) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1652 2020-03-14 8:57:26 AM PDT
[Bedside Lights
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/117) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 0B 2020-03-14 8:57:25 AM PDT
[Bill
(Bill)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/803) Virtual Presence System 226.d4ec7d51-d028-4b… 2020-03-13 7:46:31 PM PDT
[Cook Top
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/898) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 4B 2020-03-14 8:52:42 AM PDT
[Corner Light
(Generic ZigBee RGBW Light)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/459) Generic ZigBee RGBW Light System 43E3

B0CE18140001A7F3 2020-03-14 8:56:07 AM PDT
[Credenza Light
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/101) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 05 2020-03-14 9:04:07 AM PDT
[Deck Light
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/129) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 11 2020-03-14 12:06:14 AM PDT
[Deck Steps
(Generic Z-Wave Outlet)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/289) Generic Z-Wave Outlet System 32 2020-03-14 12:08:15 AM PDT
[Desk Lamp
(hueBridgeBulbCT)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1230) hueBridgeBulbCT System 999/10 2020-03-14 8:56:03 AM PDT
[Dining Room Hold
(Dining Room Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/773) Virtual Dimmer System lo03 2020-03-14 8:57:44 AM PDT
[Dining Room Light
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/103) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 06 2020-03-14 8:57:44 AM PDT
[Dishwasher
(SmartThings Multipurpose Sensor V5)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1198) SmartThings Multipurpose Sensor V5 System 2791

286D9700010742BF 2020-03-14 8:43:21 AM PDT
[Dog Door
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/141) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System 29ED

000D6F000BBD2A8D 2020-03-14 8:43:16 AM PDT
[Door To The Garage Sensor
(Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/194) Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor System 26 2020-03-14 8:49:09 AM PDT
[East Front
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/258) Aeotec Nano Switch System 2F 2020-03-13 5:50:50 PM PDT
[East Rear
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/257) Aeotec Nano Switch System 2E 2020-03-13 5:50:53 PM PDT
[Ebike
(SmartThings Presence Sensor V4)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/173) SmartThings Presence Sensor V4 System 1BCC

24FD5B0001081A94 2020-03-03 9:13:51 PM PST
[ESDND
(ESDND)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1172) Virtual Switch System 12e2b5cb-444f-426f-b… 2020-03-03 8:06:21 PM PST
[ESFlash Briefing
(ESFlash Briefing)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1170) Virtual Switch System 89f882f0-2e18-4e50-9… 2020-02-15 7:00:00 AM PST
[Espresso Grinder
(Generic Zigbee Outlet)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/131) Generic Zigbee Outlet System 0578

000D6F0005428B16 2020-03-14 6:59:57 AM PDT
[Espresso Machine
(Espresso Machine)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1610) Virtual Switch System dc1602cf-a88a-4e4e-9… 2020-03-14 6:59:58 AM PDT
[Espresso Machine Plug
(Generic Zigbee Outlet)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1607) Iris Smart Plug User 601D

000D6F000CA6F293 2020-03-14 9:05:39 AM PDT
[Everything
(everything_off)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1616) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1673 2020-03-14 8:57:26 AM PDT
[Fan
(Fan)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/98) Generic Z-Wave Switch System 02 2020-02-24 8:13:09 PM PST
[Front Door Sensor
(Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/165) Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor System 1B 2020-03-14 8:36:23 AM PDT
[Garage Bike Charger
(Generic Zigbee Outlet)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/386) Iris Smart Plug User 8E0C

000D6F000B2D7387 2020-03-14 9:02:56 AM PDT
[Garage Charger repeater
(Generic Z-Wave Repeater)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1326) Iris Z-Wave Repeater User 50 2020-03-14 9:04:53 AM PDT
[Garage Door Button
(Generic Z-Wave Relay)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/182) Generic Z-Wave Relay System 21 2020-03-12 10:07:16 PM PDT
[Garage Door Sensor
(Garage Door Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/137) SmartSense Multi Sensor System 6C5D

000D6F00057CA264 2020-03-14 9:04:30 AM PDT
[Garage Door Switch
(Garage Door Switch)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1038) Virtual Switch System c1fcc2c1-4c24-493a-b… 2020-03-14 12:05:55 AM PDT
[Garage East
(Generic Zigbee CT Bulb (dev))
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/458) Generic Zigbee CT Bulb (dev) System DC9E

B0CE18140302EE3A 2020-03-14 8:53:44 AM PDT
[Garage Followers
(Garage Followers)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1603) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1660 2020-03-14 8:53:42 AM PDT
[Garage Heat
(Generic Z-Wave Smart Switch)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/196) Generic Z-Wave Smart Switch System 27 2020-03-01 2:19:15 PM PST
[Garage Hold
(Garage Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/778) Virtual Dimmer System lo08 2020-03-14 8:53:43 AM PDT
[Garage Lights
(Garage Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1592) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1649 2020-03-14 8:53:42 AM PDT
[Garage North
(hueBridgeBulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/968) hueBridgeBulb System 999/6 2020-03-14 8:53:39 AM PDT
[Garage South
(hueBridgeBulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/969) hueBridgeBulb System 999/4 2020-03-14 8:53:39 AM PDT
[Garage West
(hueBridgeBulb)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/970) hueBridgeBulb System 999/7 2020-03-14 8:53:40 AM PDT
[Garage Workbench
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1262) Generic Zigbee Switch System 15D2

000D6F000A79254B 2020-03-14 8:53:40 AM PDT
[Gate Drive
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/328) Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor System 39 2020-03-14 7:59:03 AM PDT
[Gate Front
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/329) Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor System 3A 2020-03-14 8:15:21 AM PDT
[Hallway Ceiling Light
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/164) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 1A 2020-03-14 8:54:45 AM PDT
[Hallway Hold
(Hallway Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/775) Virtual Dimmer System lo05 2020-03-14 8:54:44 AM PDT
[Hallway Pre
(Hallway Pre)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1744) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1802 2020-03-14 8:57:26 AM PDT
[Holds
(Hold Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1609) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1665 2020-03-14 7:30:13 AM PDT
[Hot Water Loop
(Generic Z-Wave Smart Switch)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/185) Generic Z-Wave Switch System 24 2020-03-14 8:29:48 AM PDT
[Hot Water Tank
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/227) Qubino 1D Relay Module System 2C 2020-03-14 9:03:17 AM PDT
[Hue Bridge (A59E34)
(hueBridge)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/962) hueBridge System 001788A59E34 2019-08-09 12:00:00 AM PDT
[Kitchen Front
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/126) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 0D 2020-03-14 8:56:54 AM PDT
[Kitchen Front Followers
(Kitchen Front Followers)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1589) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1647 2020-03-14 8:52:39 AM PDT
[Kitchen Front Lights
(Kitchen Front)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1587) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1645 2020-03-14 8:52:43 AM PDT
[Kitchen Hold
(Kitchen Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/772) Virtual Dimmer System lo02 2020-03-14 8:56:52 AM PDT
[Kitchen Lights
(Kitchen Lights)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1586) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1644 2020-03-14 8:56:56 AM PDT
[Kitchen Mid
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/127) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 0E 2020-03-14 8:56:56 AM PDT
[Kitchen Rear
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/128) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 10 2020-03-14 8:56:53 AM PDT
[Kitchen Rear Followers
(Kitchen Rear Followers)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1588) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1646 2020-03-14 8:56:52 AM PDT
[Kitchen Rear Lights
(Kitchen Rear)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1585) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1643 2020-03-14 8:56:56 AM PDT
[Kitchen Sink
(Generic Zigbee CT Bulb (dev))
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/147) Generic Zigbee CT Bulb (dev) System 04D0

000D6F000AA99061 2020-03-14 8:52:41 AM PDT
[Kitchen Slider Sensor
(Kitchen Slider Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1135) Generic Z-Wave Contact Sensor System 4E 2020-03-14 8:34:33 AM PDT
[Kitchen Speakers
(Generic Zigbee Outlet)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/146) Generic Zigbee Outlet System 4BA3

000D6F000CA4ECD7 2020-03-14 8:02:59 AM PDT
[Kitchen Speakers Repeater
(Generic Z-Wave Repeater)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/385) Iris Z-Wave Repeater User 42 2020-03-14 8:47:52 AM PDT
[Klickitat
(SmartThings Presence Sensor V4)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/195) SmartThings Presence Sensor V4 System 6AB9

24FD5B000105A49C 2020-03-13 3:27:10 PM PDT
[Laundry Followers
(Laundry Followers)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1599) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1656 2020-03-14 8:54:33 AM PDT
[Laundry Lights
(Laundry Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1598) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1655 2020-03-14 8:54:32 AM PDT
[Leak Dishwasher
(Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/144) Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor System A946

000D6F0002F7FBCB 2020-03-14 8:34:03 AM PDT
[Leak Espresso Pump
(Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/193) Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor System 5D4A

286D97000101B528 2020-01-09 3:26:33 PM PST
[Leak Kitchen Sink
(Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/866) Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor System ADD5

286D970001038D57 2020-03-14 8:50:04 AM PDT
[Leak Recirculator
(Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/229) Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor System BB37

000D6F000A95B8BA 2020-03-14 6:09:22 AM PDT
[Leak Refrigerator
(Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/331) Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor System 34A5

286D970001021E53 2020-03-14 8:54:27 AM PDT
[Leak Tank
(Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/228) Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor System 2221

000D6F00032A03A2 2019-09-07 3:42:51 AM PDT
[Life 360 Refresh
(Life 360 Refresh)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/77) Application Refresh Button System arb-226 2018-10-25 9:54:23 AM PDT
[Living Room Ceiling
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/99) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 03 2020-03-14 9:04:07 AM PDT
[Living Room Followers
(Living Room Followers)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1594) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1651 2020-03-14 8:44:07 AM PDT
[Living Room Hold
(Living Room Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/804) Virtual Dimmer System lv16 2020-03-14 8:44:08 AM PDT
[Living Room Lights
(Living Room Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1593) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1650 2020-03-14 9:04:06 AM PDT
[Living Room Subwoofer
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/321) Generic Zigbee Switch System ACFD

000D6F000A76EAB5 2020-03-14 7:30:18 AM PDT
[Living Room Table
(hueBridgeBulbCT)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1207) hueBridgeBulbCT System 999/9 2020-03-14 8:45:13 AM PDT
[Livingroom TV
(Livingroom TV)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1134) Virtual Dimmer System f18b4e99-99b2-42a2-8… 2020-03-14 12:05:57 AM PDT
[Lock DTG
(Generic Z-Wave Lock)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/417) Generic Z-Wave Lock System 48 2020-03-14 8:54:16 AM PDT
[Lock FD
(Generic Z-Wave Lock)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/104) Generic Z-Wave Lock System 07 2020-03-14 8:41:27 AM PDT
[Main Water Shut-Off
(Dome Water Shut-Off)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/230) Dome Water Shut-Off System 2D 2020-01-21 7:42:35 PM PST
[Misc Lights
(Misc Lights)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1717) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1771 2020-03-14 8:37:09 AM PDT
[mosquitto
(mosquitto)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1584) MQTT Client User 192.168.223.4 2020-03-14 9:05:39 AM PDT
[Motion Attic
(Hue Motion Sensor Custom Hubitat DH)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/390) Hue Motion Sensor Custom Hubitat DH User 6F13

001788010211EC7A 2020-03-14 9:05:10 AM PDT
[Motion Bath
(NYCE Motion Sensor Series)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/120) NYCE Motion Sensor Series System 9F2B

000D6F000D55A06D 2020-03-14 8:52:24 AM PDT
[Motion Bedroom
(NYCE Motion Sensor Series)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/119) NYCE Motion Sensor Series System 849F

000D6F000D4C1D21 2020-03-14 8:50:21 AM PDT
[Motion Dining
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/102) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System DB7B

000D6F000BBA47D8 2020-03-14 8:50:42 AM PDT
[Motion Garage
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/175) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 918C

000D6F000BBD9B2D 2020-03-14 8:49:38 AM PDT
[Motion Hallway
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/121) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 9CB7

000D6F000BBA44F3 2020-03-14 8:50:42 AM PDT
[Motion Kitchen Front
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/641) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 2C67

000D6F000BBA95DA 2020-03-14 8:45:37 AM PDT
[Motion Kitchen Rear
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/124) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 430D

000D6F000B662F30 2020-03-14 9:01:23 AM PDT
[Motion Living Room
(Motion Living Room)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/97) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 00FA

000D6F000BBDABAF 2020-03-14 9:04:35 AM PDT
[Motion Office
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/138) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 7354

000D6F000BBEF545 2020-03-14 9:01:01 AM PDT
[Motion Patio
(Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/332) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 742C

000D6F000E0583CC 2020-03-14 8:08:31 AM PDT
[Motion Shop
(Motion Shop)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/150) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 4F69

000D6F000BBB1970 2020-03-14 8:56:14 AM PDT
[Motion Stairs
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1716) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System F92E

286D9700010BA9F7 2020-03-14 8:52:05 AM PDT
[Motion West Walk
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/355) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 02C5

000D6F000BBEF22B 2020-03-14 7:19:51 AM PDT
[Motion Yard
(Generic Zigbee Moisture Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/334) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 3FE7

000D6F000E05922D 2020-03-14 8:35:29 AM PDT
[Multisensor Deck
(Aeon Multisensor 6)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/333) AeotecMultiSensor6 User 3B 2020-03-14 9:05:39 AM PDT
[Multisensor East
(Aeon Multisensor 6)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/353) AeotecMultiSensor6 User 3D 2020-03-07 1:12:17 PM PST
[myXr
(myXr)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/545) Pushover driver System xr01 2020-03-12 10:59:05 AM PDT
[Night Lights
(Night Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1608) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1664 2020-03-14 8:57:26 AM PDT
[Office Closet
(Generic Zigbee CT Bulb (dev))
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/481) Generic Zigbee CT Bulb (dev) System 293A

B0CE18140302DE99 2020-03-13 5:50:40 PM PDT
[Office Closet Sensor
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/456) SmartSense Multi Sensor System CFD4

286D970001028E22 2020-03-14 8:25:47 AM PDT
[Office Followers
(Office Followers)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1602) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1659 2020-03-14 8:56:05 AM PDT
[Office Hold
(Office Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/771) Virtual Dimmer System lo01 2020-03-14 8:56:06 AM PDT
[Office Light
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/139) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 16 2020-03-14 8:56:06 AM PDT
[Office Lights
(Office Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1601) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1658 2020-03-14 8:56:06 AM PDT
[Outdoor Speakers
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/322) Generic Zigbee Switch System B297

000D6F0004A87E62 2020-03-13 2:57:29 PM PDT
[Outside Lights
(Outside Group)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1591) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1648 2020-03-14 3:09:14 AM PDT
[Paintbox Sensor
(Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/335) Generic Zigbee Motion Sensor System 017F

000D6F00057C962D 2018-11-16 11:41:45 PM PST
[Patio Hold
(Patio Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/780) Virtual Dimmer System lo10 2020-02-28 3:36:22 PM PST
[Patio Lights
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/130) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 12 2020-03-13 12:03:39 AM PDT
[Plumbing Repeater
(Generic Z-Wave Repeater)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1327) Iris Z-Wave Repeater User 52 2020-02-25 9:52:34 PM PST
[Plumbing Switch
(Generic Zigbee Outlet)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/388) Generic Zigbee Outlet System 16B7

000D6F000CA60D8D 2020-03-14 4:22:37 AM PDT
[Porch Light
(Porch Light)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/145) Generic ZigBee RGBW Light System B3B0

841826000007C70A 2020-03-14 12:06:12 AM PDT
[Prep
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/133) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 14 2020-03-14 8:52:42 AM PDT
[Radio Light
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/100) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 04 2020-03-14 9:04:08 AM PDT
[SBT
(SBT)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/974) Mobile App Device System 700B8CFF-8A92-459D-A… 2020-03-13 7:46:44 PM PDT
[Shop Dust Collector
(Generic Z-Wave Smart Switch)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/183) Generic Z-Wave Smart Switch System 22 2020-02-27 9:41:17 PM PST
[Shop Followers
(Shop Followers)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1604) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1661 2020-03-14 8:54:31 AM PDT
[Shop Garage Not Lights
(shop garage not lights)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1680) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1737 2020-03-14 12:06:39 AM PDT
[Shop Lights
(Generic Z-Wave Smart Switch)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/184) Generic Z-Wave Smart Switch System 23 2020-03-13 5:51:18 PM PDT
[Shop Lights Group
(shop lights)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/1681) Group Bulb Dimmer-2.1 System Group_1739 2020-03-13 3:48:24 PM PDT
[Smoke Detector Bedroom
(Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/179) Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector System 1E 2020-03-12 3:55:36 PM PDT
[Smoke Detector Dining Room
(Smoke Detector Dining Room)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/177) Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector System 1C 2020-03-13 12:22:48 AM PDT
[Smoke Detector Garage
(Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/181) Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector System 20 2020-03-12 1:35:58 AM PDT
[Smoke Detector Living Room
(Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/180) Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector System 1F 2020-03-09 7:26:07 PM PDT
[Smoke Detector Office
(Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/178) Generic Z-Wave Smoke/CO Detector System 1D 2020-03-07 6:50:26 PM PST
[West Front
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/325) Aeotec Nano Switch System 35 2020-03-13 5:51:20 PM PDT
[West Rear
(Device)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/326) Aeon Micro Switch System 37 2019-04-01 11:03:37 PM PDT
[Window Bathroom
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/455) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System ECCE

000D6F000B1134FF 2020-03-14 8:51:00 AM PDT
[Window Bedroom East
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/136) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System 340D

000D6F000B1233E6 2020-03-14 8:27:39 AM PDT
[Window Bedroom North
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/135) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System 1BB1

000D6F000B11DEF6 2020-03-14 8:41:07 AM PDT
[Window Dining East
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/105) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System 7A09

000D6F000B1B7416 2020-03-14 8:23:55 AM PDT
[Window Dining West
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/106) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System 6387

000D6F000AAF7B0F 2019-12-24 11:16:52 AM PST
[Window Kitchen Sink
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/143) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System AADE

000D6F000B11D92E 2020-01-13 3:16:19 PM PST
[Window Kitchen West
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/140) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System B75B

000D6F000BBE74AB 2020-03-14 9:01:15 AM PDT
[Window Living North
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/107) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System 202F

000D6F000B1B7A4E 2020-03-14 8:52:47 AM PDT
[Window Living South
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/108) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System 6978

000D6F000B12357F 2020-03-14 8:38:36 AM PDT
[Window Office North
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/134) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System BC71

000D6F000B11E239 2020-03-14 9:01:24 AM PDT
[Window Office West
(Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/142) Generic Zigbee Contact Sensor System 4D3C

000D6F000BBD18BB 2019-12-18 6:17:36 AM PST
[Yard Hold
(Yard Hold)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/781) Virtual Dimmer System lo11 2020-02-28 3:36:21 PM PST
[Yard Lights
(Generic Z-Wave Dimmer)
](http://192.168.223.244/device/edit/323) Generic Z-Wave Dimmer System 33 2020-03-14 3:09:14 AM PDT

Bill, are you using pre beta2 of the MQTT app ?

The log will give you the time when the command is received from MQTT (HA) and also when it is actioned (command sent to physical device) by my app and then when the device reports state back to my app and I update that on MQTT. If I can add any more useful logging let me know. It should be well under a second - it is here.

I am not aware of any identified issues with the MQTT app and slowdowns. At startup my app is processor intensive for a couple of minutes until it posts 'ready' but then it only reacts to events from devices that are being published to MQTT or incoming MQTT messages to HE devices, so mostly dormant.

Do you have any apps using Maker API - what's the control speed like on that ?

Always here to help either via PM or the MQTT topics if you think it is MQTT related.

Thanks Kevin. Yes still using pre beta2.

Next time it happens I'll try to collect a more accurate timeline, but the bottom line right now is that I don't suspect your app.

I don't have maker api installed. Again, the other place I see this issue is with the echo skill. When things get slow they get slow from echo as well. I need to verify that the slowdowns effect both zwave and zigbee. I'm not entirely certain its not a z-wave only problem.

This doesn't indicate where the problem started. The first thing that you lose when the hub is locking up is the Zigbee radio. This doesn't mean that the zigbee radio is the problem. It's a consequence. The same could be true of the Echo skill. That slowness could be due to a problem caused by another app. The fact that the Echo skill is also slow doesn't mean that it wasn't the MQTT app. It doesn't mean it was either, but you can't use that as evidence that it wasn't the MQTT app.

1 Like