App Executing But Not Doing What Log Said It Did

I have this Motion app that turns on one switch, but the light is not turning on even though the log shows that it was turned on. I'm not sure what to do about it - it's as if Hubitat isn't talking to itself.

What kind of device is pantry light? Does it work reliably from the device page?

The device is an Aeotec paddle switch and it does work reliably from the device page. I've noticed this happening with this switch and with an Enbrighten switch. The only thing in common that I can see is that they are both Motion apps.